Reasonable Compensation Explained – How to Calculate It in Your S Corp Payroll

If you own an S corporation in Oklahoma, paying yourself a "reasonable salary" is not optional — it's an IRS requirement. The problem? The IRS doesn’t define exactly what that salary should be.

That’s where this blog comes in. We’ll walk you through what reasonable compensation means, how to calculate it for your role, and how to stay compliant — while still optimizing your tax strategy.

What Is "Reasonable Compensation" for S Corp Owners?

The IRS expects any S corp owner who actively works in the business to pay themselves a wage that reflects the value of their work. That wage must:

• Be paid through payroll (with tax withholding)
• Be reported on W-2 forms
• Match the level of work performed

Taking only distributions (or a token $10K salary on $150K profit) is a red flag for IRS audit.

Learn more in What the IRS Expects From S Corp Payroll in Oklahoma

Why It Matters

Failing to pay yourself reasonably can result in:

• Back payroll taxes
• IRS penalties and interest
• A forced adjustment of your income by the IRS
• Potential revocation of your S corp status

How the IRS Evaluates Reasonable Compensation

There’s no strict formula, but the IRS uses a set of factors:

Common Criteria:

• Your job title and role in the business
• Time and effort spent working
• Skills and training required
• Industry standards
• Company size and profitability
• Comparable salaries for similar roles

Oklahoma-Specific Examples:

• A construction business owner managing multiple crews might justify $70–$100K/year
• A part-time solo consultant earning $90K net might reasonably take $45–60K in salary

At Boulanger CPA, we perform compensation analysis for each S corp client annually.

How to Calculate Reasonable Compensation

Step 1: Break Down Your Duties

Are you primarily a technician, salesperson, or executive?

Many owners wear all hats, so your salary must reflect the weighted average of those roles.

Step 2: Use Market Benchmarks

We reference tools like:

• Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) wage data
• Salary.com or Indeed salary ranges by zip code
• What you’d pay someone else to do your job

Step 3: Factor in Profitability

You must have enough profit to justify your salary. If your business is netting $40K, a $70K salary may not be reasonable.

A good rule of thumb: Pay yourself 50–70% of net business income — depending on workload.

Timing Matters

• Run payroll regularly (biweekly or monthly)
• Don’t wait until year-end to issue one lump sum
• Make sure payroll filings (941s, W-2s) match the salary paid

CPA Tip: Reasonable Salary vs. Tax Strategy

• Higher salary = more payroll tax, less audit risk
• Lower salary = less tax, higher audit risk
• The sweet spot is where your role and compensation align — and your distributions are cleanly separate

We help Oklahoma S corp owners balance this every year. Here’s how we structure payroll compliance »

FAQs – Reasonable Compensation for S Corps in Oklahoma

Q: Can I pay myself $0 if I’m reinvesting in the business?
No — if you're working in the business, the IRS expects payroll.

Q: What if I made $100K but only paid myself $10K?
That’s a major audit risk. You may owe back payroll tax.

Q: How often should I reevaluate my salary?
Annually — or whenever your role or income changes significantly.

Q: Can I base my salary on my personal expenses?
No — it's about market rate, not your lifestyle.

Q: Can my CPA help set this?
Yes. We calculate compensation benchmarks and help structure your payroll accordingly.

Need Help Calculating Your Salary the Right Way?

We’ve helped hundreds of Oklahoma S corp owners set compliant, audit-ready salaries and run payroll that aligns with their tax strategy.

Schedule a Free Payroll Consultation
View Our Per-Employee Payroll Pricing

Boulanger CPA provides S corp payroll and compensation support for business owners in Oklahoma City, Norman, Tulsa, Moore, Edmond, and across the state.